Rarely do I depart from telling stories about Sophia, but I've been "moved" enough to want to give my thoughts on a non-mommy subject. If you don't want my opinion then you'd best stop reading... ;)
SB 1070 has a lot of people very hot and bothered. People are referencing articles all over Facebook and throwing around words like "bigotry" and "fascism" if you are in support. I think it is good for people to discuss their ideas, and I wish people could get more interested in the laws of this country, but I think a lot of people are making a lot of assumptions about the feelings and motivations of others.
Most of the argument against SB1070 is based on people thinking that if Arizona police officers are allowed to ask people for their documentation to be in this country, then they are going to go around asking every person of Hispanic origin to show their papers. This assumes that officers (and lawmakers and citizens) are solely trying to get "them" out of "our" country. Maybe some very vocal people feel that way, but isn't that really just assuming the worst of
everyone? That is prejudice, too, my friend.
There is a very similar
federal law that requires aliens (legal immigrants) to carry their documentation with them at all times. If they do not provide their papers when asked by a federal authority, they can be charged with a misdemeanor, given a fine up to $1000, and taken to jail for up to thirty days. If the agents of the Department of Homeland Security are not assumed to be bigots for asking people for their documentation, why do people assume that the Arizona police are?
Could it be that there is a terrible problem with crime in Arizona that is related to people that have already broken lots of laws? If a person is here illegally, they have already decided to break laws. They have to get forged documentation to work (illegal), lie to their employers (illegal), and possibly drive around in a car that is not registered correctly and probably doesn't have insurance (illegal, illegal). Is it really a stretch that they might join gangs? They already disrespect our laws. Might they consider doing other illegal things? Is that ever OK?
The way I see it, Arizona decided that they wanted to be able to prosecute an
illegal immigrant for
all of the laws they break when they are caught doing a crime, rather than just the one crime they were initially caught doing. And
what if they see a person that they
know has been previously deported? Shouldn't they be able to walk right up to that person and ask for their documentation? How is that profiling?
I really don't see the difference between a police officer asking for a person's documentation and a federal agent asking. Do people really have that much more faith in the faith in the federal government than in a state government? Do you think they've had SO MUCH more training? I doubt it. If everyone is going to protest Arizona's law, then they also should be protesting the Department of Homeland Security for upholding the federal laws that say the same thing.
And power to you if you disagree with my logic. Please feel free to comment and enlighten me (without offensive language) because I'd love to understand if there is another angle that I missed (which I do not doubt).
If you'd like to read an interesting article about this law, check out
this site.